BYP magazine started out with different owners and I had a good relationship with them. The “
Ameraucanas” article that I wrote for them in 2007 has come up near the top of many internet searches and has been widely quoted. A few years ago I noticed they made some changes to the text of my article and thay stated on the page that their articles are regularly “vetted” and updated. Making changes to my work without my knowledge or permission didn’t go over very well and they changed it back. Recently I noticed they made changes without my consent again. They have agreed to delete the article and also the Ameraucanas "Breed of the Month" page I had sponsored.
Here is part of the original article I wrote…
Which came first the Araucana or the Ameraucana? Actually since both are now legitimate names of official APA breeds let’s say the Easter Eggers came first. They came to this country as mongrel chickens and were bred to other types of chickens. Over the past several decades some breeders bred them to look the way they wanted. Some bred for tufted and rumpless characteristics, some bred for muffs and tails and others bred for whatever they wanted. Araucanas were not developed from Ameraucanas and Ameraucanas were not developed from Araucanas. They were both bred up from Easter Eggers or mixed breed chickens.
And they changed it to this...
Which came first the Araucana or the Ameraucana? Actually, since both are now legitimate names of official APA breeds, Araucanas came first. The original Araucanas (Gallina Mapuche) are a Chilean breed so old they have no documented early history and originally believed to be a different species until later determined to be another variety of Gallus gallus domesticus. They came to this country and were bred to other types of chickens. Over the past several decades some breeders bred them to look the way they wanted. Some bred for tufted and rumpless characteristics, some bred for muffs and tails and others bred for whatever they wanted.
BYP told me "
We are going with the APA on this one". This is because the APA's Standard of Perfection says that since both Ameraucana and Araucana chickens lay eggs with blue shells Ameraucanas "
are directly linked with the Araucana stocks brought to the US in the 1930s". This APA
history is also behind Wikipedia's claim that "
The Ameraucana was developed...from Araucana chickens brought from Chile".
The encouraging news is that this past year an Alliance committee requested the APA update the wording in their Standard of Perfection, regarding the background and history of the Ameraucana.
The revised wording should read...
"Ameraucanas lay eggs with blue shells and are therefore linked with nonstandard blue egg laying mongrel stock brought to the US in the 1930s. No Araucana, as recognized by today's standard, were used in creating any variety of Ameraucana."
The APA Standard Committee was very receptive and we believe the change will appear in the next SOP they print in a few years.