John, I haven't spent a lot of time looking into this but I would tend to agree with you. I don't know why, though, there hasn't been someone these days who's actually looked into it for like a college research paper or something. And, like the difference between curled toes and crooked toes where one is due to a vitamin deficiency and the other a humidity problem or possibly genetics, I wonder if there is anything like that with the Spraddle Legs.
I usually have 1 or 2 chicks with spraddle leg a year. Can't remember for sure but it seems like they were always chicks that hatched in the turning trays and fell to the bottom because I forgot to put the eggs in the hatching tray when I should have. I've tried to fix it in the past with some of the recommended procedures seen online but I don't think with any success. I think I would up just putting them all down and today I just don't mess with it. No time for it.
If it were me, and it just showed up in a particular year and a particular breeding pen, I'd be inclined to go with genetic. Especially if I hatched out other breeds at the same time with no problems. Now, if on the other hand, I had chicks all of the sudden from several breeding pens and/or breeding popping them out like that I'd be inclined to think incubator problem. Either my Temp or Humidity wasn't reading right. (I keep one of those Walmart $5 temp/humidity things at the front of each incubator where I can glance at it regularly as I walk by a few times a day. My Sportsman is in my bathroom.
)
Just thought I'd throw that out there but, I know, you've likely already considered that.